Solo and Small Firm Practice
Scanner Technology
February
17, 2006
| Question: I
am looking for advice on (1) scanner technology I presently scan
using an HP Laserjet 3030 all in one, with the software that came
with it, to scan documents into Microsoft Word for editing & reuse,
and the results are very unsatisfactory It takes almost as long
to correct the scan as it would to type from scratch. Any
ideas on software that would improve its performance or alternatives
such as a dedicated scanner? |
Answers:
Steven G. Tyler - stevengt@bellatlantic.net
Generally,
the latest version of Omnipage Pro -- the full version, rather than the cut-down
version bundled with some scanners -- wins the most plaudits for OCR software.
With that said, the bundled software often works well enough, as long as you
make sure the input is "clean" -- straight, and without visual defects.
the type of scanner shouldn't matter, as long as it can make clean images of
the original at a sufficient resolution (300+ dpi) to allow the OCR software
a fighting chance. In general, though, I've found short documents and
highly-formatted documents (think signature lines) are often easier to retype
than to clean up. Longer documents scale up in the time to clean up, but the
initial scanning and preparation time is 'amortized' over the longer document
and results in some savings of time and effort.
Richard
S. Stolker - rstolker@stolker.com
I
use a Brother MFC-7020. It has a 20-page sheet feeder (which works quite
fast) and comes with OCR software that is as good as any I've seen. It
costs about $199 and doubles as a copier and laser printer.
Wayne
Pierce - wpierce@adventurelaw.com
Regarding
Scanning: you should check the archives; I remember this question being posed
around May or June of last year because I responded to it at that time. Since
that time, we bought the new Nuance scanning product and love it. This
software both creates PDF documents, as well as converts PDF documents into
Word format (plus a third function that we have not bothered with), which
is more service for less than one-third of the price for a comparable Adobe
product. Converting PDF into Word is not flawless, but I have an excellent
legal assistant and she is quite convinced that it is far better than re-typing
from scratch. It is almost perfect when converting a pure-text PDF.
Harry
Blondell - harry@Blondelllaw.com
I
use the Xerox 252 scanner and Paperport 10 for scanning and document conversion. The
Xerox has an automatic document feeder and excellent accuracy.
For everyday scanning, I use the Xerox and Time Matters. Mail comes in
and it’s scanned into the clients file. This creates a pdf that
can be referred to, emailed or faxed from any desk. If I need to manipulate
the document I use Paperport to convert it to WordPerfect or Word. This
process makes exhibit and document creation simple. Bob McNeill is an
excellent source of info on this process.
Royal
Shannonhouse - rshannonhousepc@attg.net
I
have HP Scanjet 5300C. Altho it is a flat-bed the software works
from the computer and it has buttons for faxing, email, etc. Apart
from the lack of multipaper feed it is excellent.
Mandy
Kallal - mandykallal@msn.com
I
have a lot of luck with Adobe Professional, using the built-in OCR technology
to word-recognize. Then cutting and pasting (or saving as) a Word document,
whichever works better.